Memories of an Old Fashioned Hallowe’en

old fashioned Hallowe'en

(The families who lived along our ‘Hallowe’en route’: Blair, Brady, Bowes, Cavanagh, Chabot, Closs, Doyle, Heney, Johnston, Jordan, Kerr, Korry, Kyle, Leonard, Majaury, Mitchell, Morrow, Munro, Murphy, Myers, Paul, Perkins, Pettigrew, Popplewell, Radford, Scott, Siebel, Somerville, Stafford, Stiller, Truelove, Turnbull, Tysick, and Webber)

What was Hallowe’en like in those days?

It doesn’t seem that long ago……….back in the 1960s and 1970s, when we couldn’t wait for that magical night in October – Hallowe’en!

The days grew shorter, crisp air blew in from the north, and an eerie silence hung over our yard, as the last few geese left for the season.  Darkness crept up our lane-way each evening, shortly after the school bus dropped us off, and bare branches cast long shadows across the Third Line.

bare trees golden

In the days leading up to the big event, we watched ‘The Great Pumpkin’, and if we felt brave enough, maybe a horror movie or two, just to put us in the spirit.

The great pumpkin

“It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown”, released Oct. 27, 1966

great pumpkin

Who could forget Janet Leigh’s blood-curdling scream in the movie ‘Psycho’, or Jessica Tandy running for her life, in Alfred Hitchcock’s movie ‘The Birds’ ?



“Pyscho”, release date, June 16, 1960 – (with Anthony Perkins, Vera Miles, John Gavin, Martin Balsam, John McIntire, and Janet Leigh)

The Birds

the birds

“The Birds”, release date – March 28, 1963, starring: Rod Taylor, Tippi Hedren, Jessica Tandy, Suzanne Pleshette, Veronica Cartwright.

The Legend of Sleepy Hollow

The living room always fell silent at our house, during Ichabod Crane’s encounter with the Headless Horseman, in “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow”…..

Icabod Crane

“The Legend of Sleepy Hollow”, original release 1949, by Walt Disney Productions

Spooky music

Sometimes, we’d listen to some music, to put us in the Hallowe’en mood!

“One-eyed, one-horned, flyin’ purple people eater”

purple people eater

“The Purple People Eater”, by Sheb Wooley, released in 1958

“He did the mash, he did the monster mash,

The monster mash, it was a graveyard smash!”

monster mash

“Bobby ‘Boris’ Pickett, released August 25, 1962.  The BBC banned the record from airplay in 1962, stating that the lyrics were too morbid.

Ouija Board


The Ouija Board was released by Elijah Bond, on July 1, 1890, as an innocent parlour game. The name was a combination of the French and German words for ‘yes’.  The boards enjoyed a heyday in the 1920s, and have remained popular through the years. They have been criticized by some religious denominations, and as recently as 2001 were burned by fundamentalist groups in New Mexico.

No Ouija Boards at the Stafford House !!

Our Mother would NOT allow us to bring a Ouija board into the house!

One year, Mary-Jane Murphy, a friend who lived in Perth, invited some of the members of our 4H Club to visit her, and try out the Ouija board in her basement rec room.

Ouija game board

I recall some of us almost jumped out of our skin that same night, when a candle flickered in the middle of our ‘session’!

candle flickering

Did something make the candle flicker, or was it just our breath, from a lot of giggling teenage girls?

TV specials

Some of our favourite t.v. shows had Hallowe’en ‘specials’:

The Munsters


“The Munsters”, first episode: September 24, 1964

The Addams Family

Addams family

“The Addams Family”, first episode, Sept. 18, 1964

Hallowe'en Costumes

Preparations were made weeks in advance – deciding what we would wear for Hallowe’en.  Anyone familiar with the late fall weather in Lanark County, knows that our costumes had to be loose enough to fit over our fall jackets.   I remember a few Hallowe’en nights when there was snow on the ground, which meant clunking around in a big pair of boots all night.

It was time to head to the attic, and find some discarded clothes and make a costume!


Kids today, would not have been impressed with our costumes.  They were homemade, and usually consisted of an old pair of pants, an old shirt, maybe some tattered sheets. No one in those days bought a pre-made costume, so we had to be creative.

costume     costume-2

costume-3      costume-4

Free Masks from Kellogg’s

In the 1950s and 1960s, Kellogg’s advertised free Hallowe’en masks on the back of their cereal boxes.  All you  had to do was cut out the mask, punch two holes in it, and add a rubber band or a string.  These were all the rage!  Especially the Tony the Tiger mask!

Kellogg's Hallowe'en masks


Tony Tiger mask


Sometimes, there were Hallowe’en parties at Glen Tay School, and we wore our costumes, and bobbed for apples.

bobbin for apples

candy sacks

Mother always helped us find a suitable sack for our candy, and we could choose between an assortment of her old pillowcases.  It was always a good idea to bring at least two pillowcases – just in case it was a busy night!


The weeks passed by, and October 31st finally arrived!

After school, we ate supper quickly, and could barely contain our excitement!

Next, we watched out the window………………………………….and waited for dusk!

spooky night

We donned our costumes, grabbed our pillowcases, and began the trek up and down the Third Line.

dark country roads

Long lanes

Some of the lanes were long.  Very long.  Very, very, long.  So, we often had a debate at the end of each lane, with our friends, and decided whether it would be worth the walk.


Up and down the Third Line we scampered, running up the long lane-ways,  and along the dark country side roads.

late fall road

Kids today, might be surprised to learn that people didn’t decorate their homes, nor did they have elaborate displays on their front steps, or in their yards.

Most people didn’t have any decorations at all, and the ones who did, usually had a single, jack-o-lantern, on their front porch.


In small, rural communities like ours, it wasn’t unusual to be invited inside, and whoever answered the door would try to guess who we were!

inviting Hallowe'en kids inside

We’d stay inside for a few minutes, and might be asked how our parents were doing, or how things were going at school. Some people would even ask us to sing a song, or tell a joke, to earn our candy.  It was all good-natured fun. Often, the person who answered the door would remind us to be careful crossing the roads, or ask us to say hello to Mother and Dad for them.

kids crossing the road

It’s true, we may not have had glamorous costumes, and the decorations were a little bit sparse in those days, but the homemade treats and goodies made up for that.

It was not uncommon to receive farm-fresh apples, loose peanuts in their shells,  homemade fudge, and Hallowe’en molasses kisses.  There was no need to check the treats before eating them.  We knew everyone, and they knew us.  They were our neighbours, our classmates, our friends.

fresh apples

peanuts   kerrs-kiss-2

best treats

So….which house on our route the tastiest treats?

By far, hands-down, the best fudge on the Third Line was at Radford’s and Korry’s.   Mrs. Radford’s fudge was legendary in the area, and Ethel Korry’s fudge was so creamy, and silky smooth! Sometimes Mrs. Korry and her daughter-in-law Merle, were still busy cutting the fudge into little squares when we arrived, and they’d wrap them, and place them in little bags for us.

(see Mrs. Radford’s fudge recipe at the end of the story!!!)

cutting-fudge     homemade-fudge

One of the best stops for trick-or-treating on the Third Line was the popular general store – Cavanagh’s – owned by Jim and Helen.

Cavanagh's store - colour

The Cavanagh’s were generous with their candy, and some of our favourite treats were the Pixie Stix, the Thrills, and the Gold Rush gum.

pixy-stix thrills-gum  gold-rush-candy

Kraft Caramels were a popular treat, and many of the neighbours would throw a handful into our pillowcases, along with some pumpkin teeth candies.

pumpkin-teeth    kraft-caramels

Our Mother often made caramel apples, with fresh apples from our orchard.



One of our favourite treats on Hallowe’en were Mother’s homemade caramel popcorn balls.  She mixed freshly-popped popcorn, with the melted caramels, in a big metal pot, on top of the old stove.  She shaped them into a ball, let them dry on a cookie sheet, and wrapped them in plastic, before handing them out at our front door.


Those were certainly nights to remember!   – Long, dark, lanes in the country, our costumes made from discarded clothes, and our pillowcase sacks!

The cool fall air, and the tall, bare, maple trees that lined the dark roads, leading up to the farmhouses, all added an air of suspense, as we ran from house to house.

Homemade treats, fresh from our neighbour’s kitchens, couldn’t be beat.

We even had a little song that we sang on Hallowe’en, and perhaps it will bring back some memories of those happy Hallowe’en nights, of our youth:

Hallowe'en song

 There weren’t many tricks…

vintage hallowe'en.JPG

There was no shortage of treats

koolaid ad


I hope you enjoyed our trip back in time, to those magical Hallowe’en nights, along the Third Line!


As promised, a recipe for the best fudge on the Third Line.

Oh the Radford family’s lane was soooooo long!  I have to admit that it wouldn’t have mattered to us kids if their lane was ten times as long, we would have gladly made the trek for a few precious pieces of Mrs. Radford’s homemade fudge!


Mrs. Radford’s Fudge:

(kindly shared with us – from Nancy (Radford) Tarle)

Mom’s Cream Candy

2 c brown sugar

½ c milk (any kind including Carnation)

¼ c butter

1 tsp vanilla

Boil the first two ingredients, stirring constantly on lowest heat required, to maintain low boil, until soft ball stage in cold water. Add butter and vanilla, (and nuts if desired).  Beat until thick, with electric mixer, then finish beating by hand until no longer shiny, and begins to harden around sides of pot.  Pour into pan.


A note of thanks to the families who lived along our ‘Hallowe’en route’. Thanks for always making us feel welcome in your homes, and thank-you for some of the best treats around!

Blair, Brady, Bowes, Cavanagh, Chabot, Closs, Doyle, Heney, Johnston, Jordan, Kerr, Korry, Kyle, Leonard, Majaury, Mitchell, Morrow, Munro, Murphy, Myers, Paul, Perkins, Pettigrew, Popplewell, Radford, Scott, Siebel, Somerville, Stafford, Stiller, Truelove, Turnbull, Tysick, and Webber


every year

And a big thanks to my Hallowe’en companions. We all spent weeks in advance of the big night, planning our homemade costumes, and these girls trudged up long country lanes with me, giggling and laughing all the way, we dodged the occasional firecracker thrown at us in DeWitt’s Corners, and they will always be a part of these special memories – you know who you are…. Patti Jordan, Debbie Majaury, Jane Munro, and Susan Munro. Thank-you for the memories. 

Hallowe'en card

Arlene Stafford-Wilson

Member, Association of Professional Genealogists
Member, Lanark County Genealogical Society
Author of 10 books: “Lanark County Christmas”, “Lanark County Comfort”, “Lanark County Collection”, “Lanark County Calling”, “Lanark County Classics”, “Lanark County Connections”, “Lanark County Calendar”, “Lanark County Chronicle”, “Lanark County Kid”, & “Recipes & Recollections”
available at local stores or email:

For more memories of Hallowe’en in the 1960s and 1970s: including memories of Tim Stafford, Judy (Stafford) Ryan, Jackie (Stafford) Wharton, and Roger Stafford:

“Recipes & Recollections: Treats and Tales from Our Mother’s Kitchen”


available in local stores, and online


(photo of Cavanagh’s store courtesy of JoAnne (Cavanagh) Butler)

5 comments on “Memories of an Old Fashioned Hallowe’en

  1. Lorele says:

    Thanks for the Halloween song. I remember singing it but forgot the words

  2. Shirley Scott says:

    What wonderful Memorie, Arlene. Thank you for sharing

  3. Mike Ciceri says:

    i’m an old friend of MJ’s and the best candy is definitely the horrible toffee treats in the witch wrappers. I still search my grandkids bags for those and the rockets. The homemade treats were horrible wait except the rice crispy squares . nice to talk with someone from the valley just noticed is was four years since any one responded. say hi to mj and i hope the gaza is still open

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s